Skip to main content
    Advanced Capital Management logo
    Advanced Capital ManagementSince 1986
    Book Your 20-Minute Benefits Review
    Last updated: Reviewed by John Ziesing, FRC

    Immediate vs. Deferred Annuities

    Income Now or Growth First? · Plain-English Guide

    The biggest decision when buying an annuity isn't which company to go with — it's when you want your income to start. Immediate annuities pay you right away. Deferred annuities let your money grow first. Here's how to decide.

    Immediate vs. Deferred Annuity Stats — 2026

    SPIA payout per $100k at age 65

    $640/mo

    SPIA payout per $100k at age 65

    Avg deferred income rider rollup, 2026

    7.25%

    Avg deferred income rider rollup, 2026

    Wait time for SPIA income

    0 yrs

    Wait time for SPIA income

    Typical deferred income wait

    5–10 yrs

    Typical deferred income wait

    Sources: LIMRA Q1 2026, AnnuityAdvantage rate survey, ACM internal data.

    Immediate Annuity (SPIA)

    Income starts within 30 days of your deposit.

    • ✓ Guaranteed monthly paycheck for life
    • ✓ No market risk, no management needed
    • ✓ Simple — one deposit, income starts
    • ✓ Best for ages 65-75+
    • ✗ Can't access lump sum once started
    • ✗ No growth phase

    Example: $200,000 deposit at age 67 → approximately $1,150-$1,300/month for life

    Deferred Annuity

    Your money grows first, income starts later.

    • ✓ Tax-deferred compounding for years
    • ✓ Higher monthly income when activated
    • ✓ Flexible — choose when to start income
    • ✓ Best for ages 50-65
    • ✗ Income doesn't start immediately
    • ✗ Surrender charges if withdrawn early

    Example: $200,000 at age 58, deferred 7 years at 6% → income base of ~$300,000 → approximately $1,500-$1,750/month at 65

    How We Help You Decide

    At Advanced Capital Management, we don't push one type over the other. We look at your whole picture — when you need income, what other sources you have (Social Security, pension, savings), and what your monthly expenses look like in St. Petersburg.

    Sometimes the answer is a combination: part immediate for income now, part deferred for higher income later. We call this an "annuity ladder" and it's one of our most popular strategies for Pinellas County retirees.

    Book Your Free Review
    Retiree enjoying guaranteed income at the beach in St. Petersburg

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is an immediate annuity?
    An immediate annuity (SPIA) converts a lump sum into monthly income payments that start within 30 days. You give the insurance company a one-time payment, and they pay you every month for the rest of your life. It's the simplest way to create a guaranteed paycheck in retirement.
    What is a deferred annuity?
    A deferred annuity lets your money grow for a set period before you start receiving income. During the accumulation phase (typically 3-20 years), your money compounds tax-deferred. When you're ready, you can convert it to income or take withdrawals.
    Which one pays more per month?
    Deferred annuities generally pay more per month when you eventually start income — because your money has had time to grow and your payout factor is higher at an older age. Immediate annuities pay less per month but start right away.
    Can I get my money back from an immediate annuity?
    With a standard life-only immediate annuity, payments stop when you pass away and there's no refund. However, most people choose options like 'life with period certain' (guarantees payments for at least 10-20 years) or 'cash refund' (beneficiaries receive remaining principal). These options reduce the monthly payment slightly.
    At what age should I buy an annuity?
    There's no one right age, but we see two common patterns: Immediate annuities work well at 65-75 when you need income now. Deferred annuities work well at 50-65 when you want to grow your money before retirement. We help each client find the optimal timing.

    Related Pages

    Ready to model your own deferred income numbers?

    Use our Income Rider Calculator to project how much guaranteed lifetime income a deferred annuity could pay you — then book a 20-minute review with John to compare immediate vs. deferred for your timeline.

    Engage a Coordinated Retirement Strategy

    Schedule a complimentary 20-minute benefits review. Advanced Capital Management will assess your current position and outline guaranteed, insurance-based solutions calibrated to your objectives.

    Book Your Free Review(727) 542-7659
    Book Free ReviewCall Now

    Concierge Suite

    Choose how we can help you today

    Advanced Capital Management · Est. 2000

    👋 Hi, I'm Ava

    Ask me anything about your retirement income.

    This site uses cookies to enhance functionality and analytics. Learn more